Skip to Content

The Pros and Cons of Electric Vehicles: What Every EV-Curious Buyer Should Know

Believe the hype about the benefits of electric vehicles, but don’t overlook their drawbacks.

By Doug Newcomb
VerifiedIllustration by Ryan LugoDigital Design Manager
2022 Volkswagen ID4 Pro charging station
MotorTrend|MotorTrend

“We always deceive ourselves twice about the people we love—first to their advantage, then to their disadvantage,” French writer and philosopher Albert Camus said. The same could be said of the cars we love, and about electric vehicles (EVs) in particular and their trade-offs. Most of us have an insufferable acquaintance who vigorously and unequivocally defends EVs. I’ve heard them (usually Tesla drivers) declare more than once: “Why would someone want to drive anything other than an EV?” Better to save your breath trying to convince these Kool-Aid quaffers there are reasons one would and wouldn’t want to own an EV over an internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicle. Let’s count the ways.

1

PRO: Bye Bye, Buying Gas

023 2024 Rove Charging Station Rolls Royce Spectre
MotorTrend|MotorTrend

One of the biggest advantages of buying an EV is that you never have to buy gas again. This means no stops at gas stations—unless you need a snack or other convenience items where they make most of their profit anyway—and never having to worry about gas prices. Also never potentially spilling a smelly, toxic, and highly flammable liquid all over your car’s exterior paint or on your hands or clothes.

2

PRO: Instant Acceleration

2021 tesla model s plaid 03
MotorTrend|MotorTrend

Remember all those videos from more than a decade back of people experiencing Tesla’s Insane Mode for the first time? Well, the thrill is still real because EVs benefit from near-instantaneous torque/acceleration. Because when the pedal hits the metal, there’s almost no lag time: The battery immediately starts delivering its juice to the electric motor or motors, which produce peak torque at 0 rpm, and spin the vehicle’s wheels, usually through a single-speed transmission that minimizes friction and losses. Contrast this with even high-performance ICE vehicles with a slower giddy-up since their horsepower and torque peaks are way higher than 0 rpm and their power gets channeled through a multi-speed transmission.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
3

PRO: A Quieter Cabin

009 2023 hyundai ioniq 5 kia ev6 battery
MotorTrend|MotorTrend

Road fatigue is real, and a primary reason drivers feel tired after a long trip has as much to do with hours of focus as it does with what automotive engineers call NVH—noise, vibration, and harshness. Automakers use sound-deadening material, active noise-cancelling, and other methods to combat NVH, but EVs are inherently quieter since they don’t have a gas engine under the hood creating hundreds of micro-explosions every second and thousands of noisy moving parts as well as an exhaust system that’s routed beneath the car and has to be muffled. The biggest NVH issues with EVs revolve around wind, road, and tire noise, but these create a quiet storm compared to even the most subtle ICE vehicles.

4

PRO: Low Maintenance

Electric vehicle front storage space without an engine.
MotorTrend

Imagine never needing an oil change or having to replace a fan belt, timing chain, radiator, or many of the other parts that regularly wear out on an ICE vehicle. Whereas a typical turbocharged four-cylinder engine and eight-speed automatic powertrain can have up to 1,500 moving parts, a typical electric motor and single-speed drive has maybe 50. While EVs still need to have such things as tires and brakes replaced, battery coolant and transmission fluid changed, and the propulsion battery and cables inspected, routine maintenance is simpler and much less costly than with an ICE vehicle.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
5

PRO: Cool Cutting-Edge Features

Interior view of a Tesla vehicle showing a driver using the touchscreen interface.
willia walker|MotorTrend

While most new vehicles come with sophisticated driver assistance systems and connected in-car infotainment, the coolest features are usually found on EVs, which typically feature more software-defined technology. Examples include Tesla’s Summon feature that can autonomously park the vehicle and then come to you afterwards, Rivian’s Camp mode that provides lighting and levels the vehicle for better night’s rest, and technology that allows some EVs to potentially power homes via its onboard battery.

6

CON: Slow and Not So Steady Charging

09 difference level 1 2 3 ev charger
MotorTrend

The quickness and convenience of filling a gas tank combined with a ubiquitous fueling infrastructure is a huge hurdle for EVs to clear. If you own an EV and have home charging, you can wake up to a full battery each morning. But for a third of the people in the U.S. who live in multi-unit dwellings, home charging is more complicated. They need to rely on public charging, and topping off a battery—even at DC fast chargers—takes time and planning. And frequently inoperable chargers, long lines of EVs waiting to charge, and even something as simple as failed payment processing can all add to the frustration of being an EV owner.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7

CON: Road Trip Troubles

001 2023 Volkswagen ID4 Long Term Run to zero
MotorTrend|MotorTrend

Even with home charging, all EV owners still need to rely on publicly available chargers on long road trips. Except in very few places in the U.S. (we’re looking at you, West Texas), gas stations are plentiful and drivers can usually just spot several from the highway, pull in, fill up, and be on their way. Road-tripping EV drivers often must carefully plan their route to ensure chargers are available and factor in charging time as part of their overall journey.

8

CON: High Prices, Faster Depreciation

41 2026 Chevrolet Blazer EV RS RWD front view
MotorTrend|MotorTrend

EVs in general cost more than the equivalent gas-powered vehicle. For example, at present, the 2026 Chevy Blazer EV starts at $46,495, while the gas-powered 2026 Chevy Blazer starts at $36,295. While Chevy Blazer EV owners save money on gas, a Vincentric 2024 US EV Cost of Ownership Analysis calculated factors such as depreciation, fuel, maintenance, and other operating costs and found that over five years the 2024 Chevy Blazer EV 2LT AWD costs $11,296 more to own over five years than the Chevy Blazer 2LT AWD. And on average, the value of EVs depreciate faster than ICE vehicles.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
9

CON: Lack of Selection

Two white Tesla electric vehicles charging at a station.
Kent Nishimura|MotorTrend

When shopping for a petrol-powered vehicle, the choices are wide and varied, with everything from low-priced compact cars to large luxury SUVs available. When shopping for an EV, although the offerings are slowly growing in number, the choices remain much more limited. GM, Ford, and Toyota were the top-selling car brands in the U.S. in 2025 and combined they offer less than 20 EVs to date, with a dozen of those coming from General Motors (Cadillac accounted for half of that number). Tesla is by far the most popular EV-only brand, selling more than 1.6 million vehicles in the U. S. in 2025, with 1.5 million of those being the Model 3 and Model Y. Recent EV startups including Rivian and Lucid have yet to fully flesh out their lineups, offering only very limited, higher-priced offerings.

10

CON: Towing Can Take a Toll

04 Ford F150 Lightning Towing Test
MotorTrend|MotorTrend

If you plan to tow a trailer or boat with an EV for any significant distance, expect to make frequent charging stops. MotorTrend testing has found that even with the largest available battery pack, a fully charged 2022 Ford F-150 Lightning electric truck provided less onboard towing energy than a regular F-150 with 4 gallons of gas in its tank. On an 80-mile route following the same methodology used to determine an EV’s MotorTrend Road-Trip Range, we towed three different camping trailers with the ’22 Ford F-150 Lightning: a 34-foot, 7,218-pound Grand Design Imagine 2910BH, a 28-foot, 5,260-pound Coachmen Freedom Express 246RKS, and a 17-foot, 3,140-pound Forest River R Pod RP-153. Using the energy consumption from these real-world tests we found that when towing the smallest trailer, the F-150 Lightning range was just 115 miles. Range fell to 100 miles with the middleweight camper and dropped to 90 miles with the largest trailer.

Headshot of Ryan Lugo
Illustration byRyan Lugo
Digital Design Manager
From a young age, Ryan was captivated by the world of cars, a passion that was ignited while watching his uncles work on their vehicles. The hands-on experience and the complex mechanics of these machines fascinated Ryan, fostering a deep love for cars that has only grown stronger over the years. This early exposure continues to fuel Ryan’s enthusiasm, driving a lifelong commitment to exploring, understanding, and appreciating all things automotive. Ryan’s love of automative translated to a passion for graphic design. He began his exploration into the field when he was attending junior high school, and since then Ryan has never stopped exploring and discovering the power of creativity and visual storytelling. Ryan is constantly seeking new ways to express ideas and push creative boundaries. Ryan enjoys outdoor activities including hiking and biking. He loves working on his 2014 Mustang GT, taking it out on the road with his brother and cousins who share the same passion for cars.

Stay Ahead of the Curve.

Get the newest car reviews, hottest auto news, and expert analysis of the latest trends delivered straight to your inbox!

By signing up, I agree to the Terms of Use (including the dispute resolution procedures) and have reviewed the Privacy Notice.

Related MotorTrend Content: Politics | Business | Tech | World | Health | Sports